Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Eric Redman's avatar

Heather, it is time to pass the "NO Shariah Law in Idaho" bill I got through the House in 2018: but got stalled in the Senate.

Eric Redman

Expand full comment
Ken Whaley's avatar

As an Idahoan, I find it deeply troubling that something of this magnitude — the construction of a Qatar-funded military facility on our soil — was announced with virtually no public transparency or state-level input. That’s not just poor form; it undermines the entire idea of federalism and local accountability.

I want to be clear: the assertion that Idaho citizens and state/local leadership were not meaningfully engaged appears to be 100% correct (based on my research). There were no public hearings that I could find. No community briefings that I could find. No invitation for feedback from the people who actually live here that I could find. And amazingly, from what I can tell, Governor Little’s office didn’t even know the announcement was coming. Neither did Senator Risch. Local officials in Mountain Home weren’t briefed in advance. We were all caught flat-footed. So yes I'd say “Idahoans weren’t asked.” Because we absolutely were not!

I’m not saying there’s zero justification for international training partnerships, but I am saying that dropping news like this out of the sky, fully baked and ready for launch, into a sovereign U.S. state is a complete disregard for the principle of local control. When something this significant is "in the works for years", as the Pentagon now claims (though I do not believe for a second) and yet nobody bothers to inform Idaho leadership? That’s not cooperation. That’s federal imposition through and through.

Representative Scott, I so very much agree with you raising the alarm. Whether folks agree with your every word or not, one thing is 100% clear: we should not be learning about this kind of deal from national press conferences. We deserve a seat at the table, especially when Idaho communities are expected to deal with the fallout.

Expand full comment
16 more comments...

No posts